[hackerspaces] will the fruits of our labors be used for good or for evil?
farmckon at gmail.com
Tue Dec 6 05:47:38 CET 2011
> With regard to hackerspaces, isn't part of the point that we're proving you DON'T need to accept money from bigwigs in order to make
> your vision a reality? Here we are liberating ourselves from the pursestrings, let's not jump straight back into them.
One of the Design Patterns for Hacker Spaces* is the 'Sponsoring
Anti-pattern'. They suggest (I agree strongly) that spaces should pay
rent and basic util's on something like membership fees. Once that is
covered, if you get extra money by a grant, cool. But *don't* get your
organization beholden to the grant-givers. Because they will and yank
your $$$ when you don't toe their line*.
Also, I dig the mention of Werner von Braun. I once had a teacher
describe him as 'Amorality in pursuit of of Engineering' in an Ethics
of Engineering. I thought that was well put. Work for the Nazi's
building bombs? Sure! Work for the USA building rockers? Sure!
Amorality + Engineering in action.
> if you don't like DARPA or DoD then you should be protesting them directly. that's your right as an American. but don't
> extrapolate to say that, on the backside, any money going from those organizations directly back to the population from
> whence it came is somehow tainted blood money and the people receiving it must be sadistic soulless bastards.
I don't think I saw 'blood money' or 'sadistic soulless bastards' in
anywhere outside that single post. Rather I did see some 'You don't
have to agree, but please consider' and 'In my mind, I would rather.'
Which seem to me a rather polite and intelligent way to discuss a
topic of ethics/morality, all things given.
Also, I'm glad someone around here can use 'whence' properly. :)
- Far McKon
http://www.FarMcKon.net "Creatively Maladjusted"
* Do a refresher if you've not read this year:
** http://jezebel.com/comcast/ ->
"Given the fact that Comcast has been a major supporter of Reel Grrls
for several years now, I am frankly shocked that your organization is
slamming us on Twitter. I cannot in good conscience continue to
provide you with funding - especially when there are so many other
deserving nonprofits in town."
More information about the Discuss